What if Charles Darwin lied? What if his theory of evolution was nothing more than a fairytale, concocted one night while he lay in alcoholic stupor, listening to the neighborhood frogs croaking?
For Darwin’s entire theory rested upon the premise that men evolved and that it was the fittest who survived. But what if in truth it was not the fittest who survived but the lame, the ugly, and all the rest deemed too useless to send into battle? More importantly, what if man never really evolved? What if his only claim to marsupial ancestry was just his tendency to scratch, scratch, scratch his nether regions, that there really was no transition from monkey to man, from ape to homo sapien because man already looked the way he still does now since day one of creation?
This, of course, is the gospel according to Dave Barry who, in Noel’s cuneiform edition of A Guide to Guys, preaches that words like manly and manhood should be castrated out of the human vocabulary since they make being male sound like a very important activity. And since being male is nothing more than simply possessing a set of minor and frequently unreliable organs, Barry summarizes guy activity since the beginning of time as follows:
While prehistoric woman pounded away on roots and green leafy things that grow out of the earth to make goulash for dinner, men perfected the art of loafing, sitting around under the guise of hunting down the mighty dinosaur when the mighty dinosaur had, in fact, become extinct several million years ago. And after eons of staggering home mighty dinosaur-less every night and then sitting around for hours again the morning after, some men eventually became so bored they began to develop agriculture and invented tools. The effort exhausted them so much, though, that by the time ancient Greece attained its Golden Age and all the women worked at refining ancient humanity’s glorious contributions to politics, science, and the arts, instead of doing something equally useful, men simply developed nude Olympics and tattooed the Nike swoosh directly onto their skin.
Then came the Middle Ages, a bleak and desolate period in history. Cultural values and standards stridently went down the sewer. And while Western Europe’s civilization descended rapidly into chaos and near barbarism, guys, of course, had the time of their lives spitting, and jousting, and egging their favorite knights and the arena lions on to a murderous rampage. (“You’re the man, Launcelot!” or “Hey lion, you call that mauling the Christian? My grandma could maul Christians better!”) And while women tilled the soil, thatched the roof, and looked after the kids, men invented the Crusades (a precursor to business travel) so they could leave home for months and years to loot, and plunder, and whack each other in the head far, far away in the Holy Land. All this traveling, in turn, led to the development of the expense report, which was the forerunner to modern literary fiction.
The Renaissance was not any better. Women slaved for the resurgence of theater and the rebirth of philosophy, science, humanism, and the arts. Guys, meanwhile, spent their time ogling Drury Lane actresses and the healthy mammary glands of naked female statues. But the female capacity for loyalty and endurance is truly amazing. Women never said a word in protest, not even when, during the age of exploration, guys spent years paddling around in a gondola and getting lost simply because it is a biological truth that guys will NEVER ask for directions. This is why it takes several million sperm cells, each one wriggling in its own direction totally confident that it knows where it is going, to locate the female egg.
But let’s skip a couple of hundred years in between and zoom in on modern man who had gone back to sitting around under the guise of engaging in productive work. For of course, man’s conception of dust four scores and seven years ago never really changed. For him, dust is still a noun, not a verb.
The nebulous, Lilliputian gray matter modern guys call brain is ill-suited not just towards comprehending dust as a verb but also towards grasping human relationships. Which explains their allergy to marriage and other forms of commitment except for concubinage and their amnesia concerning anniversaries. Modern women, therefore, should pepper everyday conversations with subtle reminders that go, “Louis, would you mind passing me that sugar, inasmuch as we have a relationship?” or “We’ve got to watch the new Lara Croft flick because we have a relationship.” or “I really like this cd better and yes Louis, we have a relationship.” and, yes, even among married couples, “Honey, there’s a burglar outside and we have a relationship, I mean you and I do.”
Tsk, tsk, tsk. Plato probably had the male species in mind when he wrote of the cave dwellers in his Allegory of the Cave. But the lengths that some guys would go to explain their existence is simply amazing. Noel bought the book so he could justify every molecule of himself to his wife. Barry, on the other hand, chopped and hewed and hacked his way through sentences and paragraphs to convince himself that he was not the only one who did not evolve, every guy in the planet didn’t too. Darwin’s theory was just that, a theory, and he, Barry, and every other guy in the planet today are no different from the ones who survived the great continental divide.
Still and all, Barry’s A Guide to Guys is one rollicking read. Good for guffaws, sniggers, and a few moments of epiphany in between. No, Darwin never lied. Man did evolve; never mind if you think every male in your house is still primitive. But heavens forbid that we should ever wake up one morning to find Dave Barry God.
Amen.